The Ignorance Trap
Every year, employer plan sponsors face the same frustrating dynamic — double-digit health plan rate increases paired with colorful broker spreadsheets explaining why costs had to go up. But accepting these continuous price spikes is no longer just a bad business decision — it’s a legal liability. Employers can no longer afford to take rate hikes lying down.
Emma Fox has dedicated her career to helping employers design alternatives to the status quo of healthcare plans. She joined a recent episode of Moving to Value Unscripted to break down the dangers of ignorance in standard benefit design and key steps to restore value.
The Dangers of Ignorance
Failing to scrutinize employer health plan data exposes companies and their individual plan fiduciaries to severe financial and legal liabilities:
Legal Liability Under ERISA & the CAA: Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and Consolidated Appropriations Act (CAA) rules, plan sponsors carry a strict fiduciary duty to manage plan assets in the best interest of employees. Failing to audit claims data or allowing hidden broker fees creates direct legal exposure to employee class-action lawsuits.
The Ignorance Trap: Spending fewer than six hours a year on health benefits and blindly trusting legacy brokers is no longer a defense. Staying with low-performing advisors who deliver 40% rate hikes without offering actionable solutions makes the employer a fiduciary liability.
Catastrophic Claims Mismanagement: Without transparent claims auditing, employers regularly overpay due to simple administrative errors such as routing high-cost specialty drugs through medical coverage instead of pharmacy benefit managers.
Unnecessary Out-of-Pocket Spend: Unchecked health plan bloat pushes corporate spend to extreme levels — sometimes double the national average — siphoning funds that could otherwise go toward employee compensation, benefits or business growth.
4 Steps to Restore Value
Plan sponsors don’t need to overhaul their entire benefit structure overnight, but they must take active control of their health plan architecture.
Audit Claims Data for Red Flags
Review plan data to uncover hidden fees, spread pricing and misplaced medical claims.
Ensure specialty medications and oncology treatments are being managed at lower-cost, high-quality places of care.
Hold Advisors Accountable to Fiduciary Standards
Move away from commission-driven brokers who rely on standard, low-value spreadsheet benchmarking.
Demand fee transparency and hire advisors who can explicitly explain how clinical care delivery impacts overall healthcare financing.
Re-Center Health Plans Around Primary Care
Integrate Direct Primary Care (DPC) and direct provider contracting to route members outside legacy carrier networks.
The Impact: While embedding DPC may increase fixed plan costs by 15–20%, overall claims spend frequently drops by 35–40% as proactive primary care prevents downstream catastrophic events.
Embrace Incremental Change
Avoid the fear of mass employee disruption by starting small.
Introduce a single high-value pathway—such as a DPC option, a transparent PBM, or direct contracting for routine surgical bundles—alongside existing offerings to prove success.
By maintaining curiosity, asking hard questions, and stepping away from status-quo broker relationships, employer fiduciaries can protect themselves from legal exposure, lower enterprise spend and deliver better care to their workforce.
________
Thank you to our members who make our work possible! As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, the Moving to Value Alliance relies on generous supporters to advance our mission of creating a value-based healthcare ecosystem with high-quality health outcomes at a reasonable cost for plan sponsors and their members. Learn more at movingtovalue.org/members.
Image ©Getty Images Signature via Canva.
