Doctors (and Patients) Deserve Direct-Pay
Why is your health insurance card the only card in your wallet without a chip?
Every other modern industry relies on immediate, secure transactions at the point of sale. Yet healthcare remains tethered to a convoluted billing machinery built on claims adjudication, prior authorization bottlenecks and layers of administrative gatekeepers that add zero clinical value.
Surgeon, health policy advisor and Apptly Health Technologies (formerly UBERDOC) Founder Dr. Paula Muto joined a recent episode of Moving to Value Unscripted to break down why the legacy health insurance model is failing both doctors and patients—and how direct-pay models can rebuild the doctor-patient relationship from the ground up.
The Reality of Modern Care Delivery
Traditional healthcare spending remains heavily centered on institutional hospital consolidation, a legacy mindset rooted in the 1960s when patients routinely spent a week in an inpatient bed recovering from surgery. Today, the vast majority of clinical medicine — from joint replacements and chemotherapy to diagnostic screenings — occurs in outpatient settings.
Yet institutional healthcare dollars continue to flow where the patient is not. For self-insured employers and workers, this administrative friction translates into relentless annual rate hikes. Employees see thousands of dollars pulled from their earnings to pay for coverage, only to face high deductibles and restricted access when they actually need a specialist.
Through Apptly, Dr. Muto built a direct-pay alternative that bypasses legacy insurance friction to connect patients and self-insured plan sponsors straight to board-certified specialists.
Key Advantages of the Direct-Pay Model:
Immediate Point-of-Care Payment for Physicians: Doctors are paid immediately at the time of the visit via credit card or Health Savings Account (HSA), removing third-party claims friction, delayed reimbursements and payer clawbacks.
Lower Administrative Costs and Healthier Practice Margins: By bypassing the roughly $60-per-claim overhead tied to insurance billing, specialists can charge a lower, transparent cash rate while retaining stronger net practice margins.
Zero Prior Authorizations or Referral Delays: Patients avoid insurance gatekeeping, allowing them to book appointments directly and skip weeks or months of waiting to see a specialist.
Transparent Pricing Without Surprise Facility Fees: Visits feature upfront, pre-set pricing that protects patients and employers from inflated hospital facility fees tacked onto standard outpatient appointments.
Dramatically Reduced No-Show Rates: An upfront transaction or holding fee ensures patient commitment, solving the 40% to 50% no-show rates typical of traditional insurance-based online scheduling systems.
Direct Access to Top Credentialed Specialists: Care is not constrained by narrow payer networks; patients can choose nearby, credentialed specialists rather than driving an hour or more just to stay in-network.
Streamlined Direct Contracting for Employers and TPAs: Third-party administrators and self-insured plan sponsors can use built-in digital navigation tools to book specialist appointments directly, cutting out health plan middleman markups.
A Comprehensive Outpatient Ecosystem: Apptly’s model connects single office visits to broader direct-pay surgical bundles through partnerships with ambulatory surgery centers via Infera Health, advanced diagnostics with Green Imaging and wholesale prescription access through Mark Cuban’s Cost Plus Drugs.
Restoring Sanity to the Balance Sheet
Primary care ACOs alone cannot bend the cost curve if high-cost specialty episodes remain trapped behind administrative barriers. By treating healthcare spending like normal, transparent purchasing and funding care directly at the point of service, employers and clinicians can finally align incentives. Moving to value doesn’t require more paperwork — it simply requires putting the transaction back into the hands of the doctor and the patient.
________
Thank you to our members who make our work possible! As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, the Moving to Value Alliance relies on generous supporters to advance our mission of creating a value-based healthcare ecosystem with high-quality health outcomes at a reasonable cost for plan sponsors and their members. Learn more at movingtovalue.org/members.
Image ©Getty Images Signature via Canva.
